Oddfellas Pub & Eatery Auburn

I had the cottage pie and it was great. My husband had a burger. He said it was good but there wasn’t any sauce on it so it was kind of bland. It looked like there was a tiny bit of mayo but it melted into the bun. The menu has lots of dishes that sound good though so we’ll be back. I think we sat in a booth that someone wrote about in a review saying the hard benches were super uncomfortable. They are hard benches but I didn’t think they were as horrible as the other reviewer. They’re fitting for an Irish pub.

On 09/20/2024, Oddfellas is where the class of 1984, Auburn High School, 40 year reunion, was held. Corina and myself attended. I remember 30 years ago when this restaurant was nothing more than a tavern. Now it's a very nice restaurant and a bar together. Our service was excellent!!! Server Jamie K. did an outstanding job! Very pleasant to talk with, and an extremely hard worker! The food is Absolutely Fantastic, and you get a lot of it. Oddfellas is a great place for getting together and for huge parties. I highly recommend this establishment to all who love good food with a wonderful atmosphere. We'll be going back again!

I recently had a fantastic dining experience at Oddfellas Pub & Eatery in Auburn. The atmosphere was welcoming and cozy, perfect for a casual meal with family and friends. Food: 1. Mac & Cheese with Ham and Bacon:** This dish was incredibly comforting and flavorful. The cheese was perfectly melted and had a delightful creamy texture. The addition of ham and bacon added a wonderful smoky and savory depth to the dish. 2. Wrap with Tater Tots:The wrap was fresh and packed with crisp lettuce, juicy chicken, and a tasty dressing. The tater tots were perfectly crispy and made a great side. 3. Burger and Fries: The burger was cooked to perfection, juicy, and topped with fresh ingredients. The fries were crispy and well-seasoned, making for a satisfying meal. Service: The service was exceptional. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. The food arrived promptly, and the server was knowledgeable about the menu. Ambiance: The pub had a rustic and charming vibe with a lively kitchen visible from the dining area, which added to the overall experience. The decor was warm and inviting, making it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal. Overall, Oddfellas Pub & Eatery exceeded my expectations. The delicious food, excellent service, and pleasant ambiance made for an enjoyable visit. I highly recommend this spot to anyone looking for a great dining experience in Auburn.

Update Sept 2024- We just visited for lunch on a Friday around Noon and it was waaay busier than I thought it would be for a weekday. All the booth tables were taken and the one empty table was hella wet like someone wiped it down but didn't dry it. So we went around the wall to sit at the tables with a bench seat. This section is SO incredibly uncomfortable and I was shocked. The tables are practically in your lap and the bench seats hit you right in the soft spot on the back of your thigh. You find yourself fidgeting and adjusting, trying to lean on the table to take your body weight off your ass but nothing works because the tables are too short for the seats. I might be chubby but many of us are and those seats are terrible. IF we ever go in person again and those are the only seats available, we will walk back out. Ruined my lunch date with my boyfriend. Oh yeah, the parking sucks too. My boyfriend and I had our first date here and we come back occasionally because we like the food and the laid back atmosphere. I have brought many friends and family here. The Cottage Pie is amazing and I crave it regularly since my Mom used to make us that for dinner all the time and it was my favorite! It's my comfort food.

Nice variety and the portions are very generous. I have been to Oddfellas several times for lunch and dinner, and this was my first breakfast there. Two of us had the breakfast sandwich, one chicken fried pork and one biscuits and gravy. Everything was exceptional. We will definitely be back

My girlfriend and I decided to try this place out after she passed it a few times going to work. So, we went for an early dinner. It wasn't too busy and we got seated right away. The atmosphere was nice. You had your bar area with the high top tables and then booths and tables in the restaurant area with a high top large group table in the middle. The waitress was very friendly and gave us suggestions based on the things she likes there. Once we decided, it came fairly quickly. I lived in Germany for many years and so I decided to try the schnitzel, it didn't disappoint. The only disappointment was at the end of the meal. When I saw there was a 3% fee for paying with a credit card. I don't like hidden costs and I would never expect to pay a business expense to pay them for my meal. In my opinion, it's a terrible business practice to pass along your business costs to your customers. Had I known before my meal I could've made a decision to stay or come back another time with cash. I think that we pay too many fees on top of fees these days. So, if you decide to try this place out, unless you don't mind paying 3% more to pay for your meal, bring cash. Otherwise it was a pleasant visit. So, I'm sure I would go again, I just have to remember to bring cash.

Oddfellas is a restaurant in Auburn that's close to the train tracks right off the highway. Parking around here can very a pain sometimes so you might have to walk a bit to get here. Inside they have dozens of tables and a bar area, alongside plenty of TVs everywhere playing mostly sports. Their menu is quite large so they have a lot of options. Portion sizes are generous but prices are very high for what you get. Flavors are alright, nothing too crazy - the Cuban sandwich was ok and the cottage pie was pretty good. The staff are friendly but very slow, we saw are server only once after our food came and it was just for the check (which was about 30 minutes post food delivered to the table). Overall this place is fine, it's got its ups and downs but I can see it being a great place to watch sports with friends for drinks.

I had the Irish nachos and Cottage Pie. Yes, that's a lot of potatoes! The Irish nachos were very good. They're essential topped tots and it's nice to share them. I enjoyed the Cottage Pie at it's very similar to a Shepard's Pie. The gravy served on the side is a nice addition too. I stopped in today and tried a pepperoni flatbread and banger & mash. They were tasty. The atmosphere was pleasant. It's a bar/pub vibe with 80's hits playing over the sound system. Both my wife and I were very pleased. Lastly, service was top notch. Our waitress was very affable and accommodating.