Buffalo Bar & Grill
[{"title": "All", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipOeTBhh997856tKoeihY46x5RgVfS4fGJRJKhmHw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Latest", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipNiUUey3YzcLVns4IkcyvU8MUNOYejOUDueHyCBw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Menu", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipMYlSyumrRGCA2wycP4Pg0v6br4W6sDwc4BJDQTw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Food & drink", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipPd4edwONYTg0YZ4yxtFCZtWmL1EcIA6ALePbDow779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Vibe", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipM1pCYyjaIbKJRp2qCflVcJR4B2emDHbslNalCnw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Beer", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipMaHuabPE6mgIlkCCzjDJdrlKd-KKpi6SB-bUwcw779-h400.jpeg"}]
Service options
Highlights
Popular for
Accessibility
Offerings
Dining options
Amenities
Atmosphere
Crowd
Planning
Payments
Children
Parking
311 S Beeline Hwy, Payson, AZ 85541, United States
Monday - Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday - Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
2610 Comments
Sheri Luce
This was our first time eating at Buffalo Bar & Grill. My husband and I both ordered the Pastrami Subs which was the Thursday Special. I ordered mine with the gluten free bun. (I had noticed before arriving that there was going to be an up charge for it when looking at their menu online) The waitress asked what we’d like for our sides and listed what was available. The only problem we had was my husband ordered his with a side of fries and I ordered a side salad. The only place it shows what the sides are are on the opposite side of the menu under “Burgers & Sandwiches.” When we received our bill we were charged an additional $3 for the side salad. Obviously $3 is not going to break the bank but it would have been nice to have been made aware of the up charge and having it on the opposite side of the menu seems a little sus. The food was delicious and the atmosphere was comfortable.
Sam Hittson
I mostly liked it. The sampler plate was a great mix of the appetizers. Well worth it. The chicken wings were good-sized cuts, and the spicy sauce was good. But the Buffalo burger was horribly undercooked. It tasted too much like raw meat. I ended up microwaving it a bit. The burger was great, just too undercooked for my taste. It was way too pricey for an everyday meal.
Tyler Burns
I asked another business in the plaza who they’d recommend for dinner and they sent me here. I was glad they did. Delicious food - I got the Wednesday special of a French Dip. One of the better French dips I’ve had in a while. The servers were all very friendly, and casual, and a fun environment (while still professional. Food came out very quickly. Glad I stopped on my way through town!
Lance Richie
Everything you'd expect and want from a small country themed bar and grill. Great spot for a lunch stop. Try there Buffalo burger, it was delicious.
kirkdk8 deed
Probably the best French dip I’ve had in a long time. Also my wife’s salad was very good!
Brian Gray
I love this place! Yes, it's a dive bar, but it has good food, good people, and spirits!! Check them out just down home people that tell it like it is!
Celeste Lovett
We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner at Buffalo Bill's. I got the buffalo burger with cowboy beans- very, very good! My husband got NY strip steak, which was cooked the way he wanted, but could have been warmer when it was served. The cowboy beans were very good, hot and spicy. Our waitress was very attentive and the service was quick. The atmosphere in the restaurant is reminiscent of an old time cowboy bar, wish we had taken a photo, truly unique. All in all an enjoyable dinner.
Fernanda Grajeda
We just have a great moment, great Burgers service and beer, great bar atmosphere. thank you!
311 S Beeline Hwy, Payson, AZ 85541, United States
Monday - Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday - Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
