Eagle NYC

Atmosphere and vibes were good! Friendly door people and descent drinks. A little on the pricey side: $25 cover and $12 for well but that was during the weekend. They have a heated patio and nice dance area that opened up later in the evening.

This is one of the best gay bars in the world. Unfortunately, after paying $25+ cover and three $15 cocktails, one bartender refused to give me water (only bottled water for $5). However, two other bartenders gave me water. Unclear management’s policy or the advantage of having a bunch of dehydrated patrons on premises.

Terrible experience - Rude bartender ruined the night. I’ve never encountered someone so bitter, disrespectful, and utterly devoid of basic courtesy as the bartender at this place. It’s clear that this person lacks even a shred of kindness or decency, making it unfortunate that they are in a job that requires interaction with people. Honestly, being the bartender of a low-grade establishment like this seems to be the absolute peak of what they’ll achieve in life – and even that is a stretch. The negativity and incompetence from this individual were palpable, and it’s clear they’re stuck in a miserable cycle of unhappiness. It’s a shame to see someone so consumed by their own personal failures that they feel the need to take it out on customers. If you value your evening and want to avoid being subjected to such a low level of service and decency, I’d recommend staying far away from this place.

$20 cover on a Sunday night??? Seriously?? My friend went in and said hardly anyone there. Bar loses money and bartenders too with no one there. Sunday used to be so much fun and crowded. Going to lose your faithful customers. Unbelievable !

Go during non-peak hours! Saturday night entry sold well over capacity, by 1am it takes >10min just to squeeze from one side of the first floor to the other. No room to stand anywhere without being pushed into, let alone dance. Wouldn’t be a big deal if I hadn’t just paid $25 to get in

The bartenders were rude and unprofessional. Wouldn't let me get a glass a water but couple did, one threw a tantrum for asking glass of water, and not one would make my mojito, Moscow Mule. They also won't give you a refill on your spilled drinks which happens. The reason why didn't lower had a hot time. In the future perhaps I won't buy drinks just dance and ask for water and stick with Shirley Temples. Because somehow I'm a weirdo.

Very good and loud music here that’s hard to find in other gay bars around NYC. Reasonable pricing and my staying here was very chill, employees were nice. I felt very welcome here unlike my FIP experience.

Amazing place. Bar staff were friendly and the atmosphere was great