Hunter & Thief
[{"title": "All", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipMPbb8tgoWV_s3e-ZGsHSiCnehp4Ej2Dzrum1JSw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Latest", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipNPMn3j96-XyWX_pxnZRQzxLbD0tMGEs-_1EY16w779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Menu", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipMonOnklah7HOVu7I-Aq_-Yr-DdYMMCkuxJmlqOw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Food & drink", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipOnled_nIdLlePgJauitJYIigje3-N5ZpnVREzWw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "Vibe", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipMYooij2hm2cZOn2JP6hVtp7gZaZDNxAd3kPReLw779-h400.jpeg"}, {"title": "By owner", "image": "https://pridespots.com/wp-content/uploads/AF1QipNWVbIk_FmrMrD-RJgvkENQFHaboa9BEP-CWHTqw779-h400.jpeg"}]
Hunter & Thief is a vibrant cocktail bar located in Lindenhurst, New York, known for its unique atmosphere and exceptional service. The establishment offers a diverse selection of craft cocktails, with a particular emphasis on classic drinks, and a menu featuring a variety of small plates designed for sharing. Guests can enjoy a cozy ambiance enhanced by thoughtful decor and a welcoming staff.
Open on select evenings, Hunter & Thief provides an inviting space for social gatherings, complete with a photo booth for added fun. The bar frequently hosts themed events, making it a popular destination for both locals and visitors looking for a lively night out. With its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Hunter & Thief has quickly become a favored spot in the community.
Service options
Highlights
Accessibility
Offerings
Dining options
Amenities
Atmosphere
Crowd
Payments
Parking
21 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, United States
Monday: Closed
Tuesday - Wednesday: 5–10 PM
Thursday: 5 PM–12 AM
Friday - Saturday: 5 PM–2 AM
Sunday: Closed
70 Comments
J V
Such a fun unique vibe. Upon making a reservation I mentioned it was for a birthday celebration and we were seated at a very nice table which was greatly appreciated. Service was great. Too many delicious drinks to choose from. We tried a few and loved them all. There are lots of small plate dishes to share. We were there close to Halloween and the decorations were awesome. Follow their social media they have many different event nights. Definitely will be back.
Ghost
I really loved my experience here. The food was nicely balanced, fresh and unique to the menu. I got the courgette and truly felt joy in my soul when eating it. The centerpieces were fresh and beautiful. The drink was crafted with care and had a fresh and beautiful garnish - I'm not sure what it was because I asked them to surprise me. Service was laid back and friendly. The atmosphere felt like a candle lit night in a second home.
Jordana Gomez
We had such a lovely experience here! The drinks were beautifully made by the bartender Brian and he even customized classic cocktails that we ordered which helped elevate the drink! The food was delicious and it was such a nice vibe. There’s also a photo booth which is so fun! We can’t wait to come back again!!
Steve G
Finally got to check this place out last night. The cocktails were great and I was surprised how good the food was too. Ended up staying for trivia too which was fun. Will definitely be back
Tom Garcia
Came here on a Tuesday night with a party of five and had nothing but pleasant surprises from the time we got there. Starting with the atmosphere, very cute place, on the smaller side, but I like it that way. Lighting, music level, and music choice were all on point, if you wanted to talk to friends, you could very easily do so and plenty well lit so you can see each other. They also have a cute little photo booth in case that tickles your fancy. Drink menu is pretty diverse, especially if you love an Old Fashioned as much as I do, they have a bunch of different options, I went for the Canadian which was very tasty. Food was great too, for apps we tried the ricotta toast, French fries, humus, corn bread and roasted carrots, all were good but I think the corn bread stole the show for me. It comes with a jalapeño butter to embrace the savory side of more southern style cornbread. For the main course I had the chopped cheese, and any bodega owner I think would be proud to have this sandwich, tasty and the perfect portion. Not to mention prices for everything seemed totally reasonable. One of the biggest appeals though, staff was very friendly and kind and never made us feel rushed. Parking is pretty easy, there is a municipal lot just down the block that has plenty of spaces, along with street parking. Would absolutely love to come back here and just get the chance to hangout more.
Jeanna Damm
Had girls night here, and we all loved the place. The floating candles and dark walls give it a cool moody vibe. They also had a photobooth which is fun. The bar is pretty long for a small space. We were drawn here for the craft cocktails and those were great too. We started with the ricotta toast which had a little kick to it but very good. I had the arugula salad special and added the grilled chicken - and it was amazing! My friends had the fried chicken sandwich and the fish & chips. I hope they expand the menu in the future because the options were limited if you're coming to eat. The only thing that was disappointing was that they were out of a few items - like some food and they were out of the wine that we wanted to have. But overall we all said that it was a really nice spot, and we'll be back with our partners for date night!
Tyler Lambrick
Visited on a Tuesday night with a group of five and experienced nothing but delightful surprises from the moment we arrived. The atmosphere is charming and cozy, which I found quite appealing. The lighting, music volume, and selection were just right, allowing for easy conversation with friends and good visibility. They even have an adorable little photo booth for those interested. The drink menu is quite varied, especially for Old Fashioned enthusiasts like myself, with several options available. I opted for the Canadian version, which was delicious. The food was excellent as well; for appetizers, we sampled the ricotta toast, French fries, hummus, cornbread, and roasted carrots. While all were tasty, the cornbread stood out, particularly with its jalapeño butter that added a savory southern twist. For the main course, I had the chopped cheese, which was flavorful and perfectly portioned, reminiscent of a quality bodega sandwich. Prices were very reasonable. One of the highlights was the exceptionally friendly and kind staff, who never made us feel rushed. Parking was convenient with a municipal lot nearby and ample street parking. I would love to return and spend more time here.
Jennifer Mugford
Run!!!!! This place is amazing! They’re currently celebrating their first anniversary and I hope they’re around for many more. Atmosphere was a little surprising when we first walked in but it totally worked. The place has a very cool vibe without trying too hard. Staff was very friendly. Music was great. The drink menu was very impressive. Tons of Old fashioned options. The food was on another level. We had the corn bread and zucchini flower appetizers which were absolutely incredible. The Fried chicken sandwich was out of this world. So crispy yet light and not too heavy or greasy. The fish and chips were literally melt in your mouth. Definitely will be back!!!
21 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, United States
Monday: Closed
Tuesday - Wednesday: 5–10 PM
Thursday: 5 PM–12 AM
Friday - Saturday: 5 PM–2 AM
Sunday: Closed
