Replay Andersonville

Never coming back after this morning, November 10th, 2024. We arrived at 11:20 am to a nearly empty restaurant, my wife, our infant in their bassinet, our three year old, and myself. Despite multiple open low tables, we were told that the investors, the OWNERS of the company, might need them, and they REFUSED to accommodate us. Having a five week old infant in a bassinet in a stroller, a high top was not an option which we explained. They didn’t care, my wife and infant had to leave this half empty restaurant leaving my three year old balling between not wanting to leave the games and not wanting to see mommy leave. Talk about NOT FAMILY FRIENDLY. We have been patrons of all of these “investors” businesses for the 7 years we have lived a few blocks away. We will NEVER BE BACK. Not the bars, not replay. Nothing. IT IS SO INCREDIBLY HARD TO GET OUT OF THE HOUSE WITH A YOUNG FAMILY, and this place does not want our business, and they will not get it again.

I love this place. Where else can you get a full service menu, a bar with great beer and bourbon selections, and for dessert decapitate someone while playing Mortal Kombat? Everything I’ve ever eaten here is great. Brunch, salads, buffalo chicken egg rolls, nachos, cheese curds, pesto chicken wrap, burgers, etc. good portions tastefully presented. The service is quick and efficient as well. They make one of the better old fashioneds in the city - always with a big cube. Love the credit card machines that come to your table instead of the typical dreadfully long wait to pay. There is also a great outside seating area that is very dog friendly. This place is tops in my book. Flawless Victory!

I've been there a couple of times because it's located in a good spot in Andersonville and the front patio is perfect. The problem is that they don't have great food and although the beer is decent (nothing extraordinary), the worst thing is the service in general. Today I went there for the last time! They tried to charge us extra for the beer. Although the price for 14oz is 8 dollars, they served us in 12oz plastic cups and charged us for 14oz. Totally unnecessary for a well-located business, with everything necessary to make an honest profit.

Great food and AMAZING service! Fast, friendly, and decently priced. Talked to the manager, Connor, too, and he made us feel very welcomed! Great to have another friendly establishment in the neighborhood we can visit! Will definitely be coming back!! ♥️

Always have a great experience here. The staff is super helpful and the drinks are tasty. The food is always great too. Love the Buffalo chicken wrap, chicken tenders, Buffalo egg rolls, and fried pickles!

Very good menu and the food was great. The prices are very high, but that is a reflection on the economy. The service was excellent, topping off drinks and making sure everything was good.

Such a fun place! Loved the atmosphere with all the retro games to play. Servers were super nice, just a little slow on getting us new drinks. (It was very busy so im not mad about it!!!) Dont even get me started on the cheese curds and birria tacos. They were insanely delish!!! Great place (:

Excellent as usual, food is always amazing, staff are friendly and helpful. Love this place